ULIP vs Mutual Fund
Enter your premium to see how ULIP charges eat returns versus a mutual fund + term insurance combo.
Runs entirely in your browser — your numbers never leave this page.
How it works
The same Rs 1.5L/year, two very different destinations:
- ULIP: market returns minus 3–4% in layered charges (allocation, mortality, admin, fund management). Early years are the worst — little of your premium actually gets invested.
- MF + term: full premium (minus a small term premium) compounding at market returns minus ~1% TER, plus 10–20x more life cover per rupee.
- The 5-year lock-in: ULIPs lock you in 5 years with surrender charges — expensive to exit once you see the drag.
- "Tax-free" pitch: ULIP maturity was tax-advantaged, but the charge drag usually exceeds any tax saving.
- Already stuck in one? After the lock-in, compare surrender value vs paid-up/continued — sometimes exiting and redirecting to MFs wins even after charges.
Frequently asked questions
Are ULIPs bad?
They're expensive: 3–4% annual charges vs ~1% for mutual funds, plus weak insurance cover. Separating investing (MF) from insurance (term) wins on both.
What charges does a ULIP have?
Premium allocation, policy admin, mortality (insurance cost), and fund management charges — layered, and heaviest in early years.
Is ULIP maturity tax-free?
Maturity had tax benefits, but the charge drag typically exceeds the tax saving. Don't buy for the tax angle.
What is the ULIP lock-in?
5 years, with discontinuance/surrender charges for early exit. You can't easily escape a bad ULIP.
I already have a ULIP — what now?
After lock-in, compare surrendering (and redirecting to MFs) vs continuing paid-up. Run the numbers; sunk premiums shouldn't drive the decision.
How much more cover does term give?
Roughly 10–20x the cover per rupee of premium versus the insurance component inside a ULIP.
Do ULIPs at least force discipline?
SIPs auto-debit just as well, without the lock-in or charges. Discipline doesn't require overpaying.
What returns do ULIPs actually give?
Market returns minus 3–4% in charges. A 12% market becomes ~8–9% in your hands — over 15 years that halves the corpus.
Are new-age ULIPs cheaper?
Somewhat — but they still bundle two products you should buy separately. The structural problem remains.
What should I buy instead?
A pure term plan for protection + mutual fund SIPs (or PPF/EPF) for investing. Simple, cheap, and transparent.